We must do the right thing.

Prof. Deon Pretorius
Time for reflection.

After two weeks of painful destruction in the Sundays River Valley it is time for serious reflection. Much of what will be stated here have been said in the recent past. Nothing is new but we need to reinforce and act in accordance with what is the right thing to do.

To repeat something that need to be said again and again: the first and most important thing to understand about the Valley is, like the rest of South Africa, is the problem of unequal distribution of socio-economic opportunities. This problem was inherited from the past, but it was also sustained and reproduced through the local education and economic systems. It places severe limits on the life chances of some people, and it enables others to achieve a good quality of life.

Let us look at it from the point of view of two children: the one born in a township in the Valley and the other born on one of the citrus farms. The children that are born and grow up in the townships have significantly less chances to achieve a good quality of life compared to the children of the farmers. The disparity starts with the differences in terms of the inherited means that parents have to provide for their children, but it is multiplied by the differences in terms of access and quality of medical /health, education, and others vital services. By the time a child is ready to enter into the world as a young adult there is a very big disparity between the life chances of the child from the township compared to the child from the citrus farm.

Sadly, this situation has not changed over more than two decades since the end of apartheid despite the advent of democracy. This was and remains the biggest problem that must be solved; we are still trapped in a vicious cycle of unequal distribution of wealth and access to wealth and life chances.

The SRVC In Context

All perceptions about the Sundays River Valley Collaborative (SRVC) must be seen against the background that this is why the Sundays River Valley Citrus Producers’ Forum (SRVCPF) created the Sundays River Valley Collaborative.

Thus, it must be understood that the SRVC was and is a response to this situation and it must be appreciated that it supported by the majority of farmers because they understand that they have to play a positive role in solving the problem of socio-economic inequality. The lack of appreciation by a small number of farmers is directly related to current crisis in the Valley.

It is never going to be easy to reduce the inequality. Part of the problem is that there are different views on how this will be done. Forcing the farmers to pay higher wages will not solve the problem. Wages is without doubt a problem, but it is not the only problem. If wages are not the only problem, what are the other problems?

We should all know that it is the state of local government, lack of effective service delivery, particularly of basic services, the state of schools, the structure of the economy, the lack of skills, and low levels of productivity, among other things.

Redistribution is Inevitable

The farmers may have to make a voluntary gesture with regards to the wages, but the more important point is that the reality of acute inequality make redistribution inevitable. The question is how this is to be done.

Unsustainable increases in wages which are not linked to productivity and the business cycles farmers go through are not going to solve these problems in a sustainable and inclusive way. Moreover, increasing wages through a strategy of coercion is not going to change the conditions in which people are living. The only way to do it is for all sectors of society to work together to develop the local communities.

 fair, just, reasonable, and developmental redistribution process must be conceived and implemented. The South African tax system is already a redistribution system in which the rich and high-income earners pay the most taxes, but it does not work very well. The system is not effective as a developmental system.
The problem is largely that the state is not using these taxes effectively and efficiently.

So, to say that you pay tax and therefore you do not have to do anything else is not only like the ostrich that puts his head in the sand, but it is also self-defeating. Besides the taxes that they pay, the farmers have no choice but to keep on investing in the system; this is part of their commitment to redistribution, but it is also their way of looking after their own interests.

Co-Responsibility for the Situation

However, the farmers cannot do it on their own; they are not solely responsible for this situation. Thus, the state and civil society should take co-responsibility and organised labour must come to the process as a responsible development-minded partner.

There are governmental instruments like the multi-department Economic Recovery Fund that was established after the riots of last year that can be used to recover and rebuild. There are also instruments to build and nurture a more inclusive, unified, and more equal future.

But the parties must get out of the blame game, stop the destruction and confrontational approach to problems, and get on with doing the right things. Opportunistic politics must end. All farmers must get on board. There is a role for everyone. That is why a Social Compact is required; so that all parties can make the appropriate commitments and to start engaging with one another according to an agreed set of rules of engagement.

Leave a reply

The Sundays River Valley Collaborative is a non-profit organization aimed at achieving inclusive socio-economic development in the Sundays River Valley.


Get in touch today and find out how you can help the SRVC create a better tomorrow for all.

Or if you wish to donate, please click the button below.


Kirkwood, Sundays River Valley, South Africa

© Copyright 2022 by RAMP Media